2 Howard Keels are better than 1.

There was only one Howard Keel. In Classic Hollywood’s glittering constellation of stars, there were plenty of tall, hunky leading men. There were singers too, with soft crooning voices (Bing Crosby and Dick Powell), and The Voice himself, Frank Sinatra. But there was only one hunky man with the rich baritone, and that was Howard Keel.

In the landscape of Hollywood musicals, the technicolor MGM musicals reigned supreme. Howard Keel appeared in some of the splashiest musicals of the 1950s, both at MGM and not, that operatic voice soaring in each song, that appeal of his always reliably virile. Surprisingly, he didn’t always sing in the movies.

In Callaway Went Thataway (1951), there are two Howard Keels, but neither of them sing. One of them is classic Keel; a jerk. My friend pointed out to me that he played unlikable characters a lot of the time. But you still love him anyway.

Deborah Patterson (Dorothy McGuire) and Mike Frye (Fred MacMurray) are two marketing execs for a TV network that airs reruns of a popular western show. Their bosses have been nagging them to locate the star, Smoky Callaway, who disappeared from the spotlight some time ago. Their prayers are answered when they find a Smoky lookalike; a cowboy named Stretch Barnes (Keel).

Singing and not, Keel had no trouble looking like a goofball 85% of the time.

Stretch is an unassuming humble guy who just wants to live the simple life. His friends have been making fun of him because he and Smoky look so much alike. When Deb and Mike appear on his ranch, offering him the chance to impersonate a famous TV star, he refuses. He isn’t interested in stardom or even the money. But eventually he’s coaxed into it. The only trouble is that the real Smoky has been located. And he isn’t at all pleased with the imposter.

Smoky is a belligerent drunk. He’s spent a lot of time in Hollywood and has become an arrogant, uncouth, womanizing star. This dual role was a great one for Howard Keel, because he was able to portray two very different types quite effectively. It’s great to see him as both a bumbling sweetheart and a boozy cad.


Stretch gets so invested in the job and all those little kids who idolize him. He even sets up a charity so that his paycheck will instead go to the kids and not him. Just the kind of sweet cowboy every red blooded American girl dreams of. And Smoky…well, let’s just say he won’t be returning to the spotlight any time soon.

There’s a great scene where the two are fighting, and Mike Frye ends up between their fists quite accidentally. It makes me want to see Fred MacMurray in more comedies.


Although Keel proved himself more than capable in non musical roles, I do still wish he sang a little in this. Then he could have looked and sounded silly. (You can catch a brief glimpse of him as a singing cowboy in Texas Carnival, if that’s something you really need in your life).

Callaway Went Thataway is a pretty hokey film, and also a good natured send up of all those popular cowboy TV shows. And it’s worth it for double the Howard Keel.



I wrote this post for the Dual Roles blogathon. Click on the banner to read more posts!

Dual Role Banners


11 thoughts on “2 Howard Keels are better than 1.

  1. Keel is excellent as both of these characters. I don’t think he got enough credit for his versatility.

    I saw Howard Keel on stage twice, both times with Jane Powell, in productions of “South Pacific” and “Seven Brides for Seven Brothers”. In “7” when he walked out on stage in that buckskin costume and started singing “Bless Your Beautiful Hide”, you could feel the whole female portion of the audience swoon!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. You’re friend makes a great point – he does play a jerk a lot, doesn’t he? It’s funny how that worked out. But yet, as you say, we still like him (though he was a bit frustrating in Annie Get Your Gone). But this sounds like a lot of fun, and fun to see him play such a sweet guy. It’s an interesting cast, too (I’m a big fan of Fred MacMurray and Dorothy McGuire).

    Thanks so much for joining in! ๐Ÿ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  3. i have got to see this one! With a cast like this, plus Howard Keel x2, it sounds like a winner. I can only imagine how fab Keel is in this film.

    Thanks for joining the blogathon, and for the introduction to this film. ๐Ÿ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Ah this obscure jewel of a ridiculous movie! I’d wondered if you’ve ever seen it to be honest. It’s one of my family’s favorites. The fight scene is my favorite.

    I must nervously admit that I’ve never been much of an admirer of Howard Keel. That’s not to say I don’t like his voice or him in general. I just recall growing up with all of the musicals he was in and always thinking… he’s alright but why is everyone swooning? Maybe I picked up on the jerk thing and it turned me off? I’m not sure (especially since certainly I had to have loved jerky male characters here and there throughout my adolescence). I don’t know, something about him has always fallen a tad flat for me. But my taste has always been impeccable /sarcasm.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I watched it in May I think and then I saw this blogathon and was excited bc I finally have an excuse to talk about this ridiculous movie! He’s absolutely insufferable in Annie Get Your Gun and Calamity Jane (I know the latter must’ve bothered you the most bc it’s Doris). I just like that he played half a jerk in this.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Dear Simoa,

    Due to your fine article for the Great Breening Blogathon, we would like very much if you could join our next blogathon, “The Singing Sweethearts Blogathon.” I believe Tiffany mentioned it to you in a previous comment, and I would like very much to know if you will be able to participate.

    If you need any suggestions, I would be glad to give some. Since you may write about movies which Jeanette and Nelson made separately, as well as the ones they made together, there are quite a few films from which to choose.

    Please let me know if you can participate. The blogathon is drawing near, and I have few participants, so I would greatly appreciate a contribution from you.

    Many thanks and good wishes!


    Rebekah Brannan


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s